This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.
Jordan Marsh Blueberry Muffins are legendary in the Boston area. We’re sharing the recipe today – including tips and tricks from the man who baked these muffins for 45 years.
There’s a saying that goes, “God is in the details.” Meaning – when attention is paid to small details, it yields great rewards. Such is the case with today’s recipe for The Real Jordan Marsh Blueberry Muffins!
Jordan Marsh Company was a New England-based department store with its flagship store located in Boston’s Downtown Crossing. Years ago, many Bostonians (including myself) made frequent pilgrimages to the Jordan Marsh bakery just for their legendary blueberry muffins.
The Jordan Marsh Blueberry Muffins were perfection! A huge, sweet, tender, cake-like muffin that baked up into a perfectly domed, sugar-crusted muffin top! Inside was a generous amount of juicy blueberries – so juicy they stained the muffin batter in parts a distinctive purple-blue color.
If you search online, there are many sites that have already shared the same version of the Jordan Marsh Blueberry Muffins recipe over the years. I’ve tried that recipe, and while the muffins were very good, they really weren’t the same as the muffins I remember eating from the Jordan Marsh bakery.
So I was thrilled to see a recent local Boston news reporter, Maria Stephanos, interview John Pupek – the now-retired baker who made the Jordan Marsh blueberry muffins for 30 years! Maria convinced John to come out of retirement to share his secret tips and tricks for making those amazing muffins. You can see her broadcast here.
As soon as we saw this news report, I knew I wanted to try making the Jordan Marsh Blueberry Muffins recipe again! And while Maria shares the muffin recipe, as written, it didn’t reflect all of those little details that John shared with her in the interview. We made three different batches of muffins – listening to the video for additional secrets before we got it right!
Our written recipe below details some specifics including:
Use a blend of bread and pastry flour (we used a 50/50 mix)
Slowly cream the sugar and shortening until lightly and fluffy. (We settled on a mix of butter and shortening. While the recipe listed butter, if you listen to the video of the interview, John mentions “shortening” – but we felt 100% shortening didn’t have as much flavor as a butter and shortening combination).
Use fortified eggs (we used Eggland’s Best which have more Omega-3 fatty acids than typical eggs) and add them gradually to the sugar/shortening mixture.
Mash ½ cup of the blueberries (this helps gives the muffins their distinctive color as well as additional moisture).
Coat the remaining blueberries with some of the flour mixture before stirring them into the batter. (In watching the video, we were certain that they used frozen blueberries rather than fresh blueberries based on the amount of juices in the bowl.)
Don’t over mix the batter, otherwise it will yield a tough muffin.
Generously grease the muffin pans with shortening – including the top of the pan. We also recommend using paper liners – the two batches we attempted without liners stuck to the pan. Then fill the muffin cups with a heaping amount of batter.
Generously coat the top of each filled muffin cup with sugar.
And this is one of our tips: To get that wonderful domed top – start with a very hot oven, then reduce to a lower temperature after baking for five minutes.
After following the tips and tricks from the news broadcast – and some trial and error of our own at home – we think these make-at-home Jordan Marsh Blueberry Muffins are very close to the real deal! Enjoy!
We love seeing what you made! Tag us on Instagram at @afamilyfeast or hashtag #afamilyfeast so we can see your creations!
The Real Jordan Marsh Blueberry Muffins Recipe
Ingredients
- 4 tablespoons butter, softened
- 4 tablespoons vegetable shortening
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- 2 whole fortified eggs such as Eggland’s Best
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 2 1/2 cups frozen blueberries, thawed
- 1 cup white pastry flour
- 1 cup bread flour
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 2 teaspoons baking powder
- 1/2 cup whole milk
- 2 tablespoons granulated sugar, for tops
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 400 degrees F with rack in the center of the oven.
- Spray the inside of a 12 cup muffin tin with pan spray (You will only be using 10 of the 12). Then, using vegetable shortening, liberally grease the top of the pan. Place muffin papers into the sprayed holes. Set the pan aside.
- In the bowl of a stand mixer, cream butter and shortening for one minute with the paddle attachment.
- Add sugar and beat on medium for about one minute.
- With the machine on medium, add one egg at a time and blend to mix. Scrape sides then beat on medium for two and a half minutes. This is important to whip air into the batter.
- Add vanilla and beat for a few more seconds to combine.
- Remove ½ cup of blueberries to a small bowl and mash with a fork or a potato masher. Set aside.
- See how much liquid the blueberries gave up. I determined that it was a bit too much and pulled ¼ cup of liquid out which I did not use in the muffins. I did leave some juice in with the blueberries however, maybe about ¼ to 1/3 cup.
- Take two tablespoons of either flour type and sprinkle over the whole blueberries and toss to coat.
- Mix both flours, salt and baking powder in a small bowl. Just stir a few times to mix.
- Start adding the flour mixture and the milk a little at a time with the mixer running. Once they are both in, do not mix further. You want to just get them incorporated without over mixing. Otherwise the muffins will be tough.
- Remove the mixing bowl to your counter and fold in the mashed blueberries. Then fold in the whole berries with the juice.
- The traditional Jordan Marsh blueberry had a purple/blue tint from the berry juice.
- Using an ice-cream scoop, divide the mixture between ten cups of the prepared 12 cup muffin tin. The batter will be piled high above the rim.
- Sprinkle the final granulated sugar over the tops of each muffin (total 2 tablespoons) and immediately place in the oven.
- Bake for five minutes then reduce the oven temperature to 375 degrees F and bake for 20 more minutes. (If your oven has a hot spot, rotate pan halfway through. Do not over bake. They will be soft but 25 minutes is plenty of time and they will bake a little further outside of the oven.)
- Remove to a rack to cool.
- Once cool, gently pry the muffins out by making sure the overhang did not stick to the pan top.
Last Step! Please leave a review and rating letting us know how you liked this recipe! This helps our business thrive & continue providing free recipes.
You may also like:
Blueberry Cream Cheese Muffins
My mother and grandmother loved Jordan Marsh muffins, and I have tried for YEARS to duplicate the muffins for them at home. Ma has since passed away, but Mom said your recipe is the closest to their taste. Thank you so much for helping me reach my goal 💙
You’re very welcome Sydney! So glad you enjoyed the muffins!
Has anyone made them in the large muffin tins (6)? If so, how long and what temp?
Thanks
Hi Judy – We haven’t tried doing so ourselves. You might find this article to be helpful: https://www.wilton.com/cms-batter-amounts.html
These are fantastic! Used only regular flour (all we had) and applesauce instead of eggs for allergy but everything else we do exactly the same and these muffins are seriously the best part of the day. We make 12 at a time in jumbo tins so we double the recipe and increase the secondary baking time to 22 min instead of 20. So far we’ve made about 50+ over the last few weeks and they’re even more amazing with raspberries (same amounts) or cinnamon apple (2 cups of diced apple per batch with no mashed apple on the side like you do with the berries and 2 teaspoons of ground cinnamon). Thanks for this recipe!!
You’re very welcome Vin! We love hearing about your adaptations – it’s helpful for other readers with food allergies to know about the ingredient swaps that still work out well. Thank you!
I made these tonight, my first time ever making blueberry muffins. While I’ve never heard of Jordan Marsh, this recipe is absolutely delicious and easy to follow. I’m highly recommending this recipe to everyone I know. I made these for breakfast but I’m not sure 12 muffins will survive overnight in my house. 🙂 Thank you for the great recipe!
You’re welcome Anne! So glad you enjoyed the muffins!
I give these 5 stars for how they looked and the nice muffin top, but the taste was not there for me….too many blueberries for my liking in one muffin. Recipe calls for a pint in only 10 muffins. It probably didn’t help that it’s not really blueberry season as well.
Thanks for taking the time to share your feedback Krystal.
Great ideas are in the air. As are great muffin ideas. I’m 67 now and fondly remember the blueberry muffins from the bakery concession at Jordan Marsh in Boson’s Combat Zone.
None of the recipes, even this one, get it right. But today, at Jumbar’s restaurant in Bethlehem, PA, I finally found the nearly perfect muffin.
The proprietor and baker never heard of Jordan Marsh. They just came up with a similar muffin.
One improvement – not just blueberries but mixed-berries. Clumps of them embedded in (and permeating) a not-too-sweet buscuit-like muffin with a few sugar crystals on the tops.
I’m sorry you were disappointed in the recipe Robert – but at least you have a bakery with similar muffins near by!
What would be a good substitute for the pastry flour?
Hi Leah – You can use all-purpose flour. The texture may be a little different but it will still work for this recipe.
Hi! Thank you for all the detailed information on the recipe. These are amazing. I would like to try them in 6 jumbo muffin tin. would you recommend a different temperature time and how long to cook?
Thank you so much for your expertise.
Hi Joelle – I’m afraid I don’t have personal experience baking these in a jumbo muffin tin. After a quick google search, this might be helpful information: https://cooking.stackexchange.com/questions/22513/how-to-convert-a-muffin-cupcake-recipe-to-a-large-muffin-recipe
I grew up near Boston and these are exactly like the Jordan marsh muffins thank you !!!!
You’re welcome Marci! So glad you enjoyed the recipe!
Haven’t made this yet, not sure if I will, autor chef says to coat bleberries with flour but you only say to coat blueberries you are going to mash, don’t want to waste food!
Hi Jacque – I’m sorry if it wasn’t clear in the recipes, we mashed some of the blueberries and coated the rest in flour before adding it to the batter.