Our Chile Colorado recipe has tender chunks of beef smothered in a deliciously rich chile sauce.
For a very long time, I was quite intimidated by those packages of dried chiles that are sold at the supermarket – sometimes near the produce section, and sometimes on the shelves of the Mexican foods section.
From watching some cooking shows, I knew that those dried chiles could be rehydrated and pureed, then added to delicious Mexican-inspired recipes – but I never really knew which peppers to buy, or how best to cook with them.
Today’s Chile Colorado recipe is a great introduction for anyone who might like to experiment with those ‘mysterious’ dried chiles – and in the end, you’ll have a flavorful, authentic Mexican dish to serve your family and friends.
What is Chile Colorado?
Chile Colorado is a traditional Mexican dish of beef or pork that is stewed in a red chile sauce until fall-apart tender. The term “colorado” in Spanish means “colored red” – so don’t mistake this as a chili recipe from the state of Colorado!
In our Chile Colorado recipe today, we used chunks of flavorful chuck beef as our meat, and we selected three types of those dried chiles: a hot and spicier New Mexico variety, and the milder California and Pasilla peppers.
Other commonly found varieties you might see at your supermarket include Ancho chiles – another milder chile from the Poblano pepper plant, or guajillo chiles – which are a hotter, spicier pepper with sweet undertones. In fact, depending on the selection of chiles you choose for your Chile Colorado, your sauce may be darker brown-red in color like ours, or a more vibrant red. *See our Notes in the recipe below for more tips about selecting the right chiles for your dish.
Once cooked, Chile Colorado is served rather simply as-is with some rice and beans on the side, or with tortillas plus cilantro and scallions for a fresh garnish. In our case – we served both! And if you have any leftovers, make our Chile Colorado Burritos.
One last comment…the packages of dried chiles that you’ll buy for this recipe will last for a while (and once you have them, they can be used in many other incredible recipes – like this one). Just be sure to store them in an air tight container for up to four months in your cabinet, longer if refrigerated.
You may enjoy these other Mexican-inspired recipes:
- Southwestern Red Chile Sauce
- Baked Chicken Taquitos
- Rocket Fuel (Homemade Hot Sauce)
- Grilled Vegetable Tostadas
- Chicken Chimichangas
4 dried mild chili peppers such as California, stems removed
4 dried mild chili peppers such as pasilla or anchos, stems removed
*2 dried hot chili peppers such as New Mexico or guajillos, stems removed (*see notes below)
2 ½ cups chicken stock, at a boil (boxed or canned is fine)
3 pounds chuck cut into 2” or larger cubes
4 tablespoons vegetable oil, divided
½ teaspoon kosher salt for beef
½ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper for beef
2 quarts beef stock (boxed or canned is fine)
2 bay leaves
2 cups yellow onion, diced
3 tablespoon fresh garlic crushed
2 tablespoons dried oregano
2 teaspoons kosher salt
1 teaspoon ground cumin
2 tablespoons tomato paste
4 tablespoons molasses
2 tablespoons red wine vinegar
Scallions chopped for serving
Cilantro for serving
6” flour tortillas for serving
Rice and beans, for serving as sides
Place all three chili peppers in a medium pan big enough to hold them laying flat and cover with the boiling hot chicken stock. Cover and let sit covered for 30 minutes.
While the peppers are rehydrating, place a medium to large Dutch oven over a burner set to high heat along with two tablespoons of the oil.
Salt and pepper the beef cubes and once the oil is hot, add half the beef not touching each other and sear for 3-4 minutes on each side until nicely browned and seared. Remove to a bowl then add the remaining oil and once hot, sear the remaining beef.
Pour the first batch of beef back into the pan and add the beef stock and bay leaves and bring to a boil. Lower to a medium simmer and cook uncovered for one hour. A medium simmer should be closer to a low boil and less like a simmer. If you don’t have the heat high enough, not enough of the liquid will evaporate and the finished sauce will be thin.
As soon as the beef is cooking, the peppers should be ready for the next step.
Add onions, garlic, oregano, salt, cumin and tomato paste to the pan with the peppers and cook for 15 minutes on medium heat, uncovered. Stir in the molasses and vinegar after the 15 minutes. Place the whole pan full of peppers and onions in a blender and puree until smooth with no lumps. (I tried an immersion blender and found the regular blender to be easier and quicker). Set this aside until the beef reaches one hour of cooking.
After the beef has cooked for one hour, stir in the pepper puree and cook uncovered for another hour at a medium simmer using a heat diffuser under the pan and stirring occasionally to make sure the beef doesn’t stick to the bottom. A medium simmer should be closer to a low boil and less like a simmer. If you don’t have the heat high enough, not enough of the liquid will evaporate and the finished sauce will be thin. Stir often so the mixture does not stick, particularly towards the end when it gets thick.
After the two hours, test the beef for tenderness and only if needed, cook a little bit longer. The sauce will be dark brown, thick and creamy once done.
Place a cover over the pot and let it sit off of the heat for 30 minutes while you prepare the beans and rice if serving along with scallions, cilantro and flour tortillas. This step is important so even if you are not serving with beans and rice, let the meat sit covered for 30 minutes off heat.
*The hot peppers can make or break a dish like this. If you like it hot, use both hot peppers with the seeds. If you like it less hot, remove the seeds and discard. If you like it very mild, remove seeds and only use one of the hot peppers. For our dish, we used two hot Mexican peppers without the seeds and I thought it was hot enough but not too hot that you couldn’t enjoy the flavor. The Mexican peppers are large in size and the guajillos are smaller and not quite as hot but still hot. I found that the Mexican pepper had better flavor, however the guajillos are more traditional, based on what I have read. The California, in my opinion, have the most flavor without heat and the Pasilla are middle of the road and mild.
One last note on dried peppers. If the pepper is dried and somewhat pliable like a raisin or prune, that is what you want to use. If it is old and dry like paper, you probably want to keep looking. That said the California pepper is a bit dry and papery under normal conditions and the other two should be somewhat soft.
Keywords: Chile Colorado